Brother Jimmy's Burger Shack

258 W 31st Street

Brother Jimmy's grew from a sort of Southern expatriate community, hungry for homestyle, regional cuisine and a place to watch local college teams like Duke and the UM Terps fight it out. By 1996, the idea had become so popular that the restaurant be... more

Brother Jimmy's grew from a sort of Southern expatriate community, hungry for homestyle, regional cuisine and a place to watch local college teams like Duke and the UM Terps fight it out. By 1996, the idea had become so popular that the restaurant became a chain, first with an Upper East Side location, then across the park, and finally into Spanish Harlem, Midtown, and even Grand Central station.

The kitschy restaurants, whether the BBQ outposts or the Baitshack and Burger Shack, are consistently jammed, owing mostly to the herd mentality of homesick locals and tourists in search of a familiar atmosphere. Most importantly, the BBQ served is of a surprisingly high order, rich in authenticity, flavorful, and almost unfailingly good.


Drag the street view to look around 360°.
Use the arrow buttons to navigate down the street and around the neighborhood!

Chelsea Description

Brother Jimmy's Burger Shack is located in the Chelsea neighborhood of Manhattan. Once a mixed, low-income neighborhood on the West Side, Chelsea has become a focal point for artists and galleries. It has a wide reputation as Manhattan's gay mecca, and while that has historically been true, rising acceptance of the gay lifestyle—and soaring rents—has led to a dissipation of the community in the neighborhood. These days, Chelsea is, very simply, a bastion of affluence more than any other social status, with the conversion of many apartment buildings to condos and co-ops and the on-rush of multimillion-dollar brownstones and lofts. In the ever-northward shift of Manhattan's masses, the high prices of Greenwich Village and Christopher Street area (which has boasted a large LGBT community since the 1960s) led many to head north to Chelsea in the late 1980s. In that migration, many have already moved on from Chelsea to the northern climes of Hell's Kitchen and Washington Heights, or east to Brooklyn. While Eighth Avenue between 14th and 23rd Streets formerly had one of New York’s highest concentrations of gay-operated restaurants, stores, cafes, the population transfer changed the demographics once again—you'll find much higher concentrations in Hell's Kitchen nowadays.

The Chelsea art scene blossomed thanks to the conversion of garages and warehouses between Tenth and Twelfth Avenues, and likely will become a victim of its own success. What SoHo and the 57th Street area lost in stature has been Chelsea’s gain, and almost all the well-established flagship galleries make Chelsea their base. How did it all begin? In 1987, the Dia Center for the Arts—later known as Dia: Chelsea—became one of the pioneers in the area, establishing its main exhibition facility on West 22nd Street. Ironically, after opening its flagship museum Dia: Beacon upstate, it was left without a Manhattan presence. Plans to move down to Greenwich Village and abut the new High Line elevated park were scuttled, and the Whitney instead grabbed the valuable tract that once appealed to Dia. Of course, the High Line further increased property values, thus begetting additional high-rises between Tenth Avenue and West Street, which in turn brought in starchitects like Frank Gehry and Jean Nouvel, whose creations can be seen soaring from the earth along West Street. You can learn more about these in our new architecture of Manhattan walking tour.

While the ethnic diversity of Chelsea was once truly enviable, the neighborhood still remains one of only a few places where housing ranges from high-rise public housing projects to single-family brownstones to new glass condominiums—even on the same block! Some of Manhattan’s most affordable rent-stabilized apartments can be found between Seventh and Ninth Avenues. The historic district has some fine examples of nineteenth-century city dwellings, and small gardens and flowering trees abound. If you think the grounds of General Theological Seminary (440 West 21st Street) look familiar, that's because it is frequently functions as a set for the TV show Law & Order! Even seminaries have to make money, and thus G.T.S. (as it's known) demolished its former entrance on Ninth Avenue to make way for (what else?) luxury condominiums. At its Tenth Avenue entrance, G.T.S. created one of Manhattan's most charming niche hotels, the Desmond Tutu Center, named after the great South African archbishop.

Speaking of hotels, Chelsea has no shortage of great places to stay and to eat. On Tenth Avenue you'll find the renowned tapas of Tia Pol and its offshoot El Quinto Pino just two blocks away. There's the upscale Cookshop nearby, and further south on Tenth Avenue you'll find the Iron Chef's Morimoto at the great Chelsea Market, also home to Buddakan on the Ninth Avenue side.

Info

258 W 31st Street
New York, NY 10128
(212) 695-5461
Website

Editorial Rating

Category

Burger

Price

$$$$$

Nearby Subway

  • to 96th St -- 0.2

@BrotherJimmys

TONIGHT!! The boys are back and we can't wait to dance the night away with oldcamryband! We'll see you on the dance…
https://t.co/Oygr8kwctu July 23

RT @Kissimmee: Get ready to “Put Some South in Yo Mouth”, @BrotherJimmys will be making its debut this #November at @PointeOrlando. The sas… July 16

RT @MurphGuide: If you are going to Billy Joel at Madison Square Garden, see our MurphGuide Directory of the bars near MSG, including @John… July 12

RT @K96121725: @AstrosCounty The best bbq I’ve ever had in NYC was at @BrotherJimmys July 12

view all

Other Burger Restaurants

Burger Bistro — Park Slope

Customizable burgers from Morton's Steakhouse alums Vincent, a classically train... view

Five Guys - Midtown

Five Guys Burgers & Fries has taken New York by storm in the already hamburger-h... view

Jackson Hole — 35th Street

With hand-scooped, made-to-order burgers, Jackson Hole has earned a reputation a... view

Brighton

Selections from GO burger and Fish Shack at the Eventi Hotel. view