Home > People
Reviews

 GURU 

walton
49
Manhattan, Gramercy
In NYC Since: 1983

The arts, artists and cityscapes 

  VIEW ALL WALTON'S REVIEWS  
 
Upstairs at Bouley

(212) 608-5829
130 West Broadway
New York, NY10013+3803

 

REVIEW

RATING

REVIEW

 

4.8

superior in all respects


Pros: exceeded my wildest expectations for casual dining
Cons: don't expect the classic white tablecloth restaurant

At first I was skeptical that such a casual atmosphere could allow for top-notch service, but I was thunderstruck by the extraordinary quality of both the food and service. I sat mere feet away from David Bouley as he cooked several courses for us, starting with a few Japanese specialties from the sushi chef, then working our way towards filet mignon and Bouley's signature lobster. I watched with glee as he prepared everything with grace and precision, at times thinking I was watching a cooking show! No detail was overlooked, from the constant changes of silverware with every course to the attentive sommelier and hostess, who repeatedly ensured that every detail was just right. Despite how intimate the kitchen space is, you can see that it is kept sparkling clean, in fact moreso than on most television shows. The staff is unhurried and we lingered for hours over a multi-course meal. The cheese course and desserts were also stunning, and our several wines selected with expert assistance from the sommelier. My highest recommendations; I've never experienced anything quite like this before in any New York restaurant.

 Send to Friend

© All rights reserved.
Posted on 7/25/2005. ( Permanent Link )
Was this review helpful to you?   [ Yes | No ]
Read 1430 Times and 1 of 2 people found this review helpful.

 
 

COMMENTS

 
 
  fresh

I wonder if you saw Frank Bruni's article ";Yes, the Kitchen's Open. Too Open."; in today's New York Times. He essentially slams this open-kitchen concept and has some pretty choice words to say about it. Link:
http://nytimes.com/2005/07/27/dining/27open.html

Posted on 7/27/2005. ( Permanent Link )


 
  awyl

"Wonderful"

Posted on 8/3/2005. ( Permanent Link )


  ADD YOUR COMMENT
 
 
This feature is only available to our registered members. If you are registered with us, please login. Not registered? Do it now in less than a New York minute!

Email Address: Password: